You've won second prize

Weirdest game of Monopoly ever.

I went into the office this afternoon before class and found Jane there. She told me that apparently our performance at the school concert won second prize which we're going to be given on Monday morning. I'm trying to work out how the judging went.

A: There was something odd about the foreign teachers.
B: Oh, they always look like that. It's nothing to worry about.
A: Yeah, I know they look odd, but I didn't mean like that.
B: They didn't have any make-up on.
A: That was it! Very avant-garde. What d'you think? Second place prize?
B: Agreed. Did you have the faintest idea what their performance was about?
A: None at all, but I do find modern theatre so baffling.
B: Me too. Now what about third place?